The Lahore High Court has ruled that a DNA test arranged privately, without the court's direction and without the mother's consent, cannot displace a child's legitimacy or end the father's duty to pay maintenance. This guide explains the ruling and what it means for parents.
A father living in the United Kingdom disowned his young son and produced a DNA report from a private laboratory to prove the boy was not his. The Lahore High Court has rejected that approach: a child born during a valid marriage is legally the husband's child, and a DNA test arranged privately — without the court's direction and without the mother's consent — cannot take that status away. DNA testing is now cheap and widely available, and it is increasingly raised in maintenance and custody disputes.
What happened in the case
The couple married on 18 August 2019 and had two sons; the younger, Abdul Rafay, was born on 27 April 2022. The wife said the husband expelled her with the younger child, while the elder son stayed with his paternal grandparents.
She sued in the Gujranwala family court for maintenance, dower and dowry articles. It awarded Rs10,000 a month for the child and Rs12,000 a month for her iddat period; on appeal, the judge raised the child's maintenance to Rs25,000 a month, with a 10 per cent annual increase, and awarded the dowry articles or Rs970,000 in their place.
The father challenged those decisions in the Lahore High Court, relying on a DNA test from a private United Kingdom laboratory, done on 5 September 2022 — more than four months after the birth — which reported paternity excluded.
Case reference: W.P. No. 50430 of 2026, Usama Tahir & others v. Zainab Irfan & others, Lahore High Court, Justice Asad Ali Bajwa, heard 21 October 2026; reported in Dawn on 18 November 2026 and Dunya News on 16 November 2026.
A note on sources: Sources: Dawn (18 Nov 2026), Dunya News (16 Nov 2026), Samaa TV, and the judgment sheet as circulated. The Lahore High Court's official judgments database (data.lhc.gov.pk) was unreachable on the morning of 18 November 2026, so the ruling could not be confirmed on the court's own website and no reported citation could be verified. Press reports spell the father “Osama Tahir”; the judgment sheet gives “Usama Tahir”.
What the High Court held
Justice Asad Ali Bajwa dismissed the father's petition in an eight-page judgment, leaving the lower courts' findings intact — noting that under Article 199 the Court could not interfere with concurrent findings absent a jurisdictional error or a material misreading of evidence.
Legitimacy is presumed by law. Under Article 128 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984, a child born during a valid marriage is conclusive proof of legitimacy, and a unilateral DNA report cannot displace that presumption. The marriage was intact when the child was born — the father's own witnesses admitted it.
A secret DNA test violates fundamental rights. Collecting a child's biological sample without the court's authorisation and without the mother's consent interferes with the child's privacy, liberty and bodily autonomy. The Court referred to Articles 4, 9 and 14 of the Constitution, which protect due process, liberty and human dignity.
Timing matters. Citing a Supreme Court ruling, the Court noted that under Muslim personal law a father must challenge paternity within 40 days of birth. The child was born on 27 April 2022; the test was done on 5 September 2022, well after that period, so the report could not be a valid ground for challenging paternity.
The child's welfare comes first. DNA testing is a serious judicial act, to be approached with caution: a court must assess whether it is necessary to meet the ends of justice and serves the child's best interests. A test ordered or supervised by a court, with proper consents, is a different matter — this ruling bans the shortcut, not testing itself.
The maintenance award — and why it stood
The father also challenged the enhanced maintenance of Rs25,000 a month. The Court refused to interfere. Maintenance turns on the child's reasonable needs and the father's means together, and covers far more than food, clothing and accommodation: education, medical treatment, housing and the child's development all count.
The wife claimed the father earned Rs1.2 million a month in the United Kingdom. She had no documentary proof, but his own witnesses admitted he lived there and sent money into a family bank account — enough, the Court held, to support her claim. A father's duty does not disappear because he produces no income documents: the court looks at his earning capacity, which arises whenever he can earn; it passes to the paternal grandfather only if the father lacks the means and cannot earn.
Your practical checklist
- Do not arrange a DNA test privately — a unilateral report will not displace the presumption under Article 128.
- If paternity is genuinely in issue, raise it through the court promptly — the challenge must come within 40 days of birth.
- Keep the marriage record, birth certificate and hospital records: they prove the child was born during a valid marriage.
- Claim maintenance on the child's full needs — food, clothing, housing, education and medical care.
- If the father lives abroad, gather evidence of his earnings and remittances — bank statements and transfer records.
- If a private DNA report is produced against you, ask your lawyer to challenge it: no court direction, no consent, and a breach of the child's privacy.
Frequently asked questions
Can a private DNA test disprove my child's paternity in court?
No. A privately arranged DNA test — without the court's direction and the mother's consent — cannot displace the conclusive presumption of legitimacy under Article 128 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984.
Can a court ever order a DNA test?
Yes, but only through the court and with proper safeguards, where testing is necessary and serves the child's best interests.
Does a father still have to pay maintenance if he denies paternity?
Yes, where the child was born during a valid marriage — the child remains legally his and the duty to maintain continues. Here the Court upheld Rs25,000 a month with a 10 per cent annual increase.
What if the father lives abroad and hides his income?
The court looks at his earning capacity and overall circumstances, not only at the documents he produces — living abroad and sending money home can itself show he earns enough.
Related guides
- How to Increase Child Maintenance in Pakistan
- How to Enforce a Family Court Decree in Pakistan
- Guardianship Certificate for a Minor in Pakistan
- Nafaqah: The Husband's Duty of Maintenance During Marriage
Need guidance on your situation? Whether you are claiming maintenance for your child, facing a paternity dispute, or dealing with a parent who lives abroad, an early confidential consultation can clarify your options. Contact us to book a consultation.
Common questions
No — not on its own. The Lahore High Court has held that a DNA test arranged privately, without the court's direction and without the mother's consent, cannot displace the conclusive presumption of legitimacy under Article 128 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984, where the child was born during a valid marriage.
Yes, but only through the court and with proper safeguards. The court must be satisfied that testing is necessary to meet the ends of justice and serves the best interests of the child. Secretly obtaining a child's DNA sample without court authorisation and the mother's consent violates the child's fundamental rights.
Yes, where the child was born during a valid marriage. The child remains legally his, and the duty to maintain continues. In this case the Lahore High Court upheld maintenance of Rs25,000 a month with a 10 per cent annual increase for the minor child.
The court looks at his earning capacity and overall financial circumstances, not only at the documents he chooses to produce. Living abroad and sending money home can itself support a finding that he earns enough to pay. The duty to maintain arises whenever he has capacity to earn.
Related guides
- Increasing Child Maintenance Pakistan
- Enforcing Family Court Decree Pakistan
- Guardianship Certificate Minor Pakistan
Need guidance on your matter? Book a Consultation
This article provides general legal information, not legal advice for your specific matter. Online contact does not create an advocate–client relationship.