The Sindh High Court has dismissed a father's constitutional petition for custody of his young son, holding that the child's welfare — not the father's status as natural guardian — decides custody, and upheld the Rs. 25,000 monthly maintenance with a 5% annual increase.

A father asked the Sindh High Court for custody of his young son, a fresh trial, and lower maintenance. On 2 November 2026, the Court refused. Custody stays with the mother, the Rs. 25,000 monthly maintenance with a 5% annual increase stands, and the father was told to use the visitation time he already has — or ask the Guardian Court for more.

Case reference: C.P. No. S-700 of 2025, Muhammad Anwar Ahmed Siddiqui v. Mst. Izza Fakhri & others, High Court of Sindh at Karachi, Justice Zulfiqar Ali Sangi, decided 2 November 2026; listed on the Sindh High Court's official caselaw website as 2026 SHC KHI 2141.

What happened in the case

The couple have one son, Muhammad Shuraim Ahmed Siddiqui. When the marriage broke down, the wife filed Family Suit No. 3671 of 2022, seeking dissolution by khula, dowry articles, and maintenance for herself and the minor; the husband applied under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, for permanent custody. The cases were consolidated.

The family court fixed interim maintenance at Rs. 10,000 a month and regulated the father's visitation. In March 2024 it allowed the mother to produce additional documents and modified the schedule. On 10 September 2024 it dismissed the father's custody application, decreed the wife's suit, raised the minor's maintenance to Rs. 25,000 a month with a 5% annual increase, and appointed the mother sole guardian.

The father appealed. On 15 April 2025 the appellate court partly allowed the appeal: it set aside the mother's appointment as guardian and the guardianship certificate, because the mandatory formalities under Sections 7 and 10 of the 1890 Act had not been fulfilled. Custody and maintenance were left untouched. The father then challenged those decisions and a further order of 29 May 2025 before the High Court.

What the High Court held

First, custody turns on the child's welfare, not on the father's title. The paramount consideration is the minor's welfare, not either parent's rights. Natural guardianship gives a father no absolute right to custody and does not automatically displace the mother's preferential right of hizanat. The boy had lived with his mother since infancy and was about two when the family court decided; nothing showed his welfare was endangered with her, and the father gave no cogent reason to disturb it.

Second, the father had been heard. He said he had no chance to lead evidence, but the record showed several opportunities, and the mother produced for cross-examination on dates he did not use. Article 10-A does not entitle a litigant to delay proceedings indefinitely, and Order XVII Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 lets a court proceed where a party fails to do what is needed.

Third, the complaint about additional documents failed. The mother was allowed to produce further documents in March 2024; the father received the material and the chance to challenge it and cross-examine her, and never challenged that order. Merely producing a document does not prove it true, and an allegation that documents were manipulated or AI-generated needs admissible material, produced at trial — not bare assertion.

Fourth, the maintenance figure stands. The amount turns on the child's necessities, the cost of living, the father's capacity, and the child's standard of living. The rise from Rs. 10,000 to Rs. 25,000 a month, with a 5% annual increase, reflected the cost of living. The father had also not challenged the amount before the appellate court, so he could not reopen it now.

Fifth, visitation must be real, not illusory. A child needs the love, affection and guidance of both parents, and divorce does not end that relationship. But no parent has an unrestricted right to take the child from the mother. The father had not fully used the visitation already granted; the Court preserved his liberty to ask the Guardian Court for more time, including on special occasions.

Finally, the guardianship certificate point was already decided in the father's favour, and Article 199 jurisdiction is extraordinary, not a second appeal: interference needs a patent illegality, a jurisdictional defect, a material irregularity, or perversity. None was shown, and the petition was dismissed.

Why this ruling matters for parents

For fathers, the message is practical. Natural guardianship is a starting point, not a winning argument: you must show, with evidence, that the child's welfare lies with you. Use the visitation you are given — unused time counted against the father here. Challenge maintenance at the appeal stage, not years later. If you call the other side's documents forged or AI-generated, bring proof at trial.

For mothers, custody of a very young child who has always lived with you is difficult to disturb, and maintenance is fixed on the child's needs and the father's means. Keep a record of hearings and visitation. For grandparents: meetings with paternal grandparents can be sought from the Guardian Court.

Checklist: if custody or visitation is disputed

  • Put the child's welfare first — schooling, health and routine.
  • Use every visitation slot and keep a dated record.
  • Challenge maintenance at the appeal stage.
  • Dispute a document at trial with admissible proof.
  • Keep certified copies of decrees and orders.

Frequently asked questions

Can a father get custody of a young child in Pakistan?

Yes, but custody is decided on the child's welfare, not on the father's status. Natural guardianship does not automatically displace the mother's preferential right of hizanat; a father must show with evidence that the child's welfare lies with him.

Does the mother automatically keep custody after khula?

No — custody follows the welfare of the child in each case. Here the boy had lived with his mother since infancy and was about two when the family court decided, and nothing showed his welfare was endangered with her.

Can child maintenance be challenged in the High Court?

Only in a limited way. Article 199 is not a second appeal: the High Court interferes only for patent illegality, a jurisdictional defect, material irregularity or perversity. The amount turns on the child's needs, the cost of living, and the father's means.

What if the other parent does not follow the visitation schedule?

Apply to the Guardian Court, which can enforce or modify the arrangements. The High Court directed that the visitation in force be implemented in its true letter and spirit.

Related guides

Need guidance on your situation? If custody, visitation or child maintenance is disputed, contact us to book a confidential consultation.

Common questions

Yes, but custody is decided on the child's welfare, not on the father's status. Natural guardianship does not automatically displace the mother's preferential right of hizanat; a father must show with evidence that the child's welfare lies with him.

No — custody follows the welfare of the child in each case. Here the boy had lived with his mother since infancy and was about two when the family court decided, and nothing showed his welfare was endangered with her.

Only in a limited way. Article 199 is not a second appeal: the High Court interferes only for patent illegality, a jurisdictional defect, material irregularity or perversity. The amount turns on the child's needs, the cost of living, and the father's means.

Apply to the Guardian Court, which can enforce or modify the arrangements. The High Court directed that the visitation in force be implemented in its true letter and spirit.

Related guides


Need guidance on your matter? Book a Consultation

This article provides general legal information, not legal advice for your specific matter. Online contact does not create an advocate–client relationship.